Internal Control · 2025
In this section9 topics
- Internal Control — Board Opinion1 item
- Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System1 item
- Internal Control Deficiencies2 items
- Audit Committee & Auditor Observations2 items
- Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Related Party Transactions1 item
- Counterparties & Transactions3 items
- Policy & Future Trends2 items
Internal Control — Board Opinion
Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control
The Board of Directors approves the internal control adequacy assessment report. The assessment utilizes the Internal Control Adequacy Assessment Form, encompassing risk management, and aligns with the Internal Control - Integrated Framework issued by The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO). This framework guides the company's internal control adequacy evaluation and comprises five essential internal control components:
(1) Control Environment
(2) Risk Assessment
(3) Control Activities
(4) Information & Communication and
(5) Monitoring Activities
Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System
Internal Control Framework Used
| Framework | Detail |
|---|---|
| COSO - Enterprise Risk Management Framework (ERM) | The 1st Audit Committee Meeting 2025 held on February 22, 2025, with all 3 Audit Committee members in attendance, the Audit Committee approved the Company's and its subsidiaries' internal control report in accordance with the COSO - ERM framework, covering all 5 components: Control Environment, Risk Assessment, Control Activities, Information and Communication, and Monitoring and Evaluation. The Audit Committee is of the opinion that the Company's and its subsidiaries' internal control system is adequate and appropriate. The Company and its subsidiaries have allocated sufficient personnel to effectively implement the system. The Company also has an internal control system in place to monitor and oversee the operations of its subsidiaries to mitigate financial and operational risks, prevent fraud and errors, enhance the reliability of financial reporting, and appropriately improve the efficiency and effectiveness of work processes. |
| The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) | The 1st Board of Directors' Meeting 2026, held on February 21, 2026, with all 4 independent directors in attendance, the Board of Directors assessed the internal control system of the Company and its subsidiaries by inquiring information from the management. The Board approved the assessment form prepared by the management and the report of the Audit Committee. The Board concluded that, from the assessment of the internal control system of the Company and its subsidiaries in 5 aspects, namely, control environment, risk assessment, control activities, information and communication systems, and monitoring activities, the internal control system of the Company and its subsidiaries is adequate and appropriate. The Company and its subsidiaries have allocated sufficient personnel to operate the system effectively. The Company also has an internal control system to monitor and supervise the operations of its subsidiaries to prevent the assets of the Company and its subsidiaries from being misused or used without authority by the directors or management, including transactions with persons who may have conflicts of interest and related parties. |
Internal Control Deficiencies
Introduction
The Board of Directors is of the opinion that the Company and its subsidiaries have adequate and appropriate internal control systems, and there were no internal control deficiencies during the past year.
Number of Deficiencies
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Audit Committee & Auditor Observations
Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's
No
Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control
No
Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
Head of Internal Audit
3159
Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
The 1st Audit Committee Meeting 2022, held on February 26, 2022, Mrs.Nongluk Nounnunta was appointed as Head of Internal Audit, effective from February 26, 2022. This appointment stems from her 7 years of experience in internal audit practice and her participation in relevant training programs, including: Risk Management Training (Basic and Advanced) COSO ERM 2017 Batch 2/62, COSO 2013 Framework for Internal Control (Basic and Advanced) Batch 1/62, Internal Control and Risk Management Assessment for Each System Based on COSO 2013 ERM and Fraud, Internal Audit Management, Continuous Auditing, 21st Certified Internal Auditor (CIA) Program, and Integrated Internal Audit for Procurement and Accounts Payable. Her understanding of the company's business and operations makes her well-suited for this position. The appointment, removal, or transfer of the Head of Internal Audit requires approval or consent from the Audit Committee. The qualifications for the Head of Internal Audit are outlined in Appendix 3.
Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit
Requires Audit Committee Approval
Yes
Description
The practice for the appointment, removal, and transfer of the Head of Internal Audit is as follows:
1. Appointment : The Audit Committee shall consider and approve the appointment of the Head of Internal Audit, taking into account appropriate qualifications such as internal audit competency, experience, and independence. The appointment must be in accordance with good corporate governance principles and demonstrate transparency and credibility in the performance of duties.
2. Removal: The Audit Committee may consider removing the Head of Internal Audit if it is found that the Head of Internal Audit is unable to perform their duties as expected or if there are reasons why they cannot hold the position, such as lack of competence, conflicts of interest, or inappropriate conduct. The removal must follow a transparent process and take into account fairness.
3. Transfer: The transfer of the Head of Internal Audit must be considered by the Audit Committee and must be based on the appropriateness of the organization and the required workload. The transfer must be carried out with caution and without affecting the independence of the Head of Internal Audit. The Audit Committee must ensure that the Head of Internal Audit in the new position will be able to perform their duties effectively and independently.
These actions are aimed at ensuring that the internal audit function is independent and can operate effectively, free from influence from management or other interested parties.
Related Party Transactions
Has Related Party Transactions
Yes
Counterparties & Transactions
Monetary Unit
1000000
Counterparties with Potential Conflicts
| Name | Person / Juristic Person | Type of Business | Nature of Relationship | As of Date (YYYY-MM-DD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. CRC Environmental Cure Co.,LTD. (CEC) | Juristic Person | Waste collection service | 1. The legal entity has shareholders holding a total of 67.90% of the registered capital, while the remaining 32.10% is divided as follows: 1) Mr. Kanchana Apinyawatcharakul holds 20.00% of the company’s shares, and 2) Mr. Taweesak Nimapan holds 10.00%, with both being related to Mr. Chalermsak Nimapan, a shareholder of the company. 3) Mr. Pitchaya Suwansaya holds 2.10% of the company’s shares and is related to Mr. Pattanapong Suwansaya, an executive of the company (previously a subsidiary, but later restructured to clarify it as a company within the shareholder group). 2. On February 1, 2021, the company purchased 7,000 shares of CRC Environmental Co., Ltd. from shareholders, with some sellers being related parties to the company. The shares represent 70% of the common stock. 3. The company shares directors with Mr. Theeraphat Chirapipat and Mr. Chalermsak Nimapan. | 2025-12-31T00:00 |
| 2. Chiangmai Rimdoi - CRC Environmental Cure Joint Venture | Juristic Person | Waste collection service | 1. A joint venture between Chiang Mai Rim Doi (since December 12, 2014), holding 5% of the joint venture's registered capital, and CEC holding 95% of the joint venture's registered capital. 2. The company shares directors with Mr. Theeraphat Chirapipat and Mr. Chalermsak Nimapan. | 2025-12-31T00:00 |
| 3. Mr.Thirapat Chirapipat | Person | 1. The director, the authorized signatory director, and a shareholder of the company holding 24.01% of the registered capital. 2. Currently holds the position of Managing Director of the company. | 2025-12-31T00:00 | |
| 4. Mr. Chalermsak Nimapan | Person | 1. The director, the authorized signatory director, and a shareholder of the company holding 8.01% of the registered capital. 2. Currently holds the position of Deputy Managing Director of the Administrative Division of the company. | 2025-12-31T00:00 | |
| 5. Mrs.Savitre Chirapipat | Person | A shareholder of the company holding 9.49% of the registered capital. | 2025-12-31T00:00 | |
| 6. Mr.Surapol Sriweraskul | Person | A director and a shareholder of the company holding 2.50% of the registered capital. | 2025-12-31T00:00 | |
| 7. CRD Property Co., Ltd. | Juristic Person | Construction Service | 1. The legal entity in which the company holds 100% of the registered capital (the company was incorporated on January 27, 2022). 2. The company shares directors with Mr. Theeraphat Chirapipat and Mr. Chalermsak Nimapan. 3. Formerly named Chiang Mai CRD Co., Ltd., the name change was registered on March 5, 2025. | 2025-12-31T00:00 |
Transactions by Counterparty
| Transactions |
|---|
| 0.01 · Necessity: In accordance with the terms agreed upon with the employees. · Description: CRD has other income from utility fees for providing accommodation to the employees and workers of CEC in the staff housing at the waste collection project, according to the agreed-upon rates. · As of yesteryear: 0.02 · Nature of transaction: Other receivables. · Audit committee opinion: The 1st Audit Committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, considered and concluded that the mentioned item is appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.03 · 14.72 · Necessity: The item is necessary as it supports the company's regular business related to waste management. The pricing is reasonable when compared to the risks and responsibilities under the terms of the contract the company has with the municipality, and the conditions in the contract are appropriate in case the company needs to deal with other third parties. · Description: CRD has accrued expenses from contracts for garbage collection and waste disposal work in the area of Lampang Municipality, waste management and garbage collection in the area of Pak Kret Municipality, and waste management and garbage collection in the area of Chiang Mai Municipality with CEC. · As of yesteryear: 29.19 · Nature of transaction: Accrued wages according to the contract. · Audit committee opinion: The 1st Audit Committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, considered the item with the primary focus on maximizing benefits for the company and its shareholders. · As of year before yesteryear: 26.22 · 1.5 · Necessity: The item is necessary as it is a short-term loan for working capital in the business. The interest rate is reasonable and close to the rate charged by financial institutions to the company. · Description: CRD has interest expenses from a loan borrowed from CEC on January 4, 2023, amounting to 7.5 million Baht for short-term working capital. The interest rate is 6.15% per year, the same rate that CRD receives from financial institutions for short-term loans. · As of yesteryear: 7.5 · Nature of transaction: Short-term loan. · Audit committee opinion: The 1st Audit Committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, considered and concluded that the mentioned item is appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 7.5 · 0.04 · Necessity: the item is necessary as it is a short-term loan for working capital in the business. The interest rate is reasonable and close to the interest rate charged by financial institutions to the company. · Description: CRD has interest expenses from a loan borrowed from CEC on January 4, 2023, amounting to 7.5 million Baht for short-term working capital. The interest rate is 6.15% per year, the same rate that CRD receives from financial institutions for short-term loans. · As of yesteryear: 0.91 · Nature of transaction: Accrued interest. · Audit committee opinion: The 1st Audit Committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, considered and concluded that the mentioned item is appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.46 · 0.22 · Necessity: In accordance with the terms agreed upon with the employees. · Description: CRD has other income from utility fees for providing accommodation to the employees and workers of CEC in the staff housing at the waste collection project, according to the agreed-upon rates. · As of yesteryear: 0.25 · Nature of transaction: Other income. · Audit committee opinion: The 1st Audit Committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, considered and concluded that the mentioned item is appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.26 · 0.29 · Necessity: The item is necessary as it is a short-term loan for working capital in the business. The interest rate is reasonable and close to the interest rate charged by financial institutions to the company. · Description: CRD has interest expenses from a loan borrowed from CEC on January 4, 2023, amounting to 7.5 million Baht for short-term working capital. The interest rate is 6.15% per year, the same rate that CRD receives from financial institutions for short-term loans. · As of yesteryear: 0.46 · Nature of transaction: Interest expenses. · Audit committee opinion: The 1st Audit Committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, considered and concluded that the mentioned item is appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.46 · 84.9 · Necessity: the mentioned item is necessary as it supports the company’s regular business related to waste management. The pricing is reasonable when compared to the risks and responsibilities under the terms of the contract the company has with the municipality, and the conditions in the contract are appropriate in case the company needs to deal with other third parties. · Description: CRD has entered into a subcontract agreement with CEC, where the terms for calculating the payment are in accordance with the same principles as the contract for the work that CRD has entered into with the municipality: - Garbage Collection in the Area of Lampang Municipality: The contract is for 57 months (from January 1, 2020, to September 30, 2024), with monthly payments based on weight per ton. The contractor will calculate the weight of the garbage collected, with a maximum of 85 tons per day, at a rate of 760.47 Baht per ton. - Waste Disposal by Landfilling in the Landfill of Lampang Municipality (within the areas of Lampang Municipality and Khelang Municipality): The contract is for 53 months (from May 1, 2020, to September 30, 2024), with monthly payments based on weight per ton. The contractor will calculate the weight of the garbage collected, with a maximum of 80 tons per day, at a rate of 165.94 Baht per ton. - Waste Management and Collection in Pak Kret Municipality: The contract is for 60 months (from April 1, 2021, to March 31, 2026), with monthly payments based on weight per ton. The rates are as follows: 514 Baht per ton (April 2021–March 2022), 620.60 Baht per ton (April 2022–March 2023), 529.65 Baht per ton (April 2023–March 2024), 556.40 Baht per ton (April 2024–March 2026), but the payments shall not exceed the contracted monthly rate. - Waste Management and Collection in Chiang Mai Municipality: The contract is for 12 months (March 1, 2023–February 29, 2024) and (March 1, 2024–February 28, 2025), with monthly payments of 3,049,500 Baht as specified in the contract. - Waste Disposal by Landfilling in the Landfill of Lampang Municipality (within the area of Lampang Municipality): The contract is for 36 months (from October 1, 2024, to September 30, 2027), with monthly payments based on weight per ton. The contractor will calculate the weight of the garbage collected and divide it into two scenarios: 1. Monday to Friday, up to 130 tons per day, at a rate of 166.52 Baht per ton. 2. Saturday to Sunday, up to 80 tons per day, at a rate of 166.52 Baht per ton. · As of yesteryear: 97.86 · Nature of transaction: Cost of services. · Audit committee opinion: The 1st Audit Committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, considered the item with the primary focus on maximizing benefits for the company and its shareholders. · As of year before yesteryear: 101.59 · 12.6 · Necessity: Such payments are necessary to demonstrate the success of the business, generate consistent revenue (dividend yield), and incentivize investors. The rationale is that they should be made when the company is profitable, has sufficient liquidity according to legal requirements, and typically come from stable companies. · Description: As of December 1, 2025, CRC Environmental Cure Co., Ltd. paid dividends to shareholders totaling 12,600,000 baht, in proportion to its 70% investment. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Dividend income · Audit committee opinion: The 1st Audit Committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, considered the item with the primary focus on maximizing benefits for the company and its shareholders. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 |
| 0.14 · Necessity: The transaction is necessary as it involves a short-term loan for working capital purposes, and the interest rate is reasonable and comparable to the rate charged by financial institutions to the company. · Description: CRD has interest expenses from loans borrowed from CRC-CEC in March 2022 for 20 million Baht, May 2022 for 8 million Baht, and March 2023 for 3.4 million Baht, to be used for short-term working capital. The interest rates were 5.25% and 6.35% per year. Subsequently, in May 2023, CRD entered into an agreement to convert the short-term loan into a long-term loan with the joint venture, setting a repayment schedule of 48 installments with an interest rate of MLR-1% per year. In September 2024, CRD entered into a loan agreement with the joint venture for 10 million Baht to be used for short-term working capital, with an interest rate of 7.05% per year. · As of yesteryear: 1.21 · Nature of transaction: Accrued interest. · Audit committee opinion: The 1st Audit Committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, considered and concluded that the mentioned item is appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.56 · 4.5 · Necessity: The transaction is necessary as it involves a short-term loan for working capital purposes, and the interest rate is reasonable and comparable to the rate charged by financial institutions to the company. · Description: CRD has interest expenses from loans borrowed from CRC-CEC in March 2022 for 20 million Baht, May 2022 for 8 million Baht, and March 2023 for 3.4 million Baht, to be used for short-term working capital. The interest rates were 5.25% and 6.35% per year. Subsequently, in May 2023, CRD entered into an agreement to convert the short-term loan into a long-term loan with the joint venture, setting a repayment schedule of 48 installments with an interest rate of MLR-1% per year. In September 2024, CRD entered into a loan agreement with the joint venture for 10 million Baht to be used for short-term working capital, with an interest rate of 7.05% per year. · As of yesteryear: 4.5 · Nature of transaction: Short-term loan. · Audit committee opinion: The 1st Audit Committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, considered and concluded that the mentioned item is appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 4.5 · 8.62 · Necessity: The transaction is necessary as it involves a loan for working capital purposes, and the interest rate is reasonable and comparable to the rate charged by financial institutions to the company. · Description: CRD has interest expenses from loans borrowed from CRC-CEC in March 2022 for 20 million Baht, May 2022 for 8 million Baht, and March 2023 for 3.4 million Baht, to be used for short-term working capital. The interest rates were 5.25% and 6.35% per year. Subsequently, in May 2023, CRD entered into an agreement to convert the short-term loan into a long-term loan with the joint venture, setting a repayment schedule of 48 installments with an interest rate of MLR-1% per year. In September 2024, CRD entered into a loan agreement with the joint venture for 10 million Baht to be used for short-term working capital, with an interest rate of 7.05% per year. · As of yesteryear: 15.05 · Nature of transaction: long term loan · Audit committee opinion: The 1st Audit Committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, considered and concluded that the mentioned item is appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 18.8 · 1.0 · Necessity: The transaction is necessary as it involves a short-term loan for working capital purposes, and the interest rate is reasonable and comparable to the rate charged by financial institutions to the company. · Description: CRD has interest expenses from borrowing money from CRC-CEC in March 2022 for 20 million Baht, in May 2022 for 8 million Baht, and in March 2023 for 3.4 million Baht, all for short-term working capital purposes. The interest rates are 5.25% and 6.35% per annum. Later, in May 2023, CRD entered into an agreement to amend the loan agreement with the joint venture to convert the short-term loans into long-term loans, with repayment terms set for 48 installments at an interest rate of MLR-1 per annum. · As of yesteryear: 1.37 · Nature of transaction: Interest expense · Audit committee opinion: The 1st Audit Committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, considered and concluded that the mentioned item is appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.55 · 0.4 · Necessity: The item is appropriate and in accordance with the shareholding proportion and the agreed-upon terms. · Description: As of January 30, 2025, the joint venture paid dividends to shareholders in the amount of 400,000 Baht, according to the investment proportion of 5%. · As of yesteryear: 0.5 · Nature of transaction: Dividend income · Audit committee opinion: The 1st Audit Committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, considered and concluded that the mentioned item is appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 |
| 0.0 · Necessity: It was part of the group's restructuring efforts to eliminate potential conflicts of interest that might arise in the future regarding the waste management business. The sale price of the shares was deemed reasonable and close to the book value per share of CEC. This transaction is expected to generate additional returns from the investment, stemming from the net profit generated from the various ongoing projects of CEC that the company has already undertaken. · Description: Mr. Thirapat Chirapipat sold 3,015 common shares of CEC to CRD at a price of 3,300 Baht per share, totaling 9.95 million Baht. CRD made a payment of 3.98 million Baht for the purchase of the investment in the subsidiary to the seller on February 18, 2021, leaving a balance of 5.97 million Baht, which was due for payment on December 30, 2021, December 30, 2022, and December 30, 2023, with equal installments. Subsequently, the company issued a letter on November 15, 2021, requesting an extension for the payment of the shares for installments 2-4. On December 1, 2022, the company requested to further extend the payment term for installments 2-4, along with a late payment penalty at an interest rate of 5% per annum, starting from January 30, 2022, except for the installment that has not yet reached its due date, until the full payment for each installment of the share purchase is made. The new payment schedule was adjusted as follows: Installment 2 to be paid on December 30, 2025; Installment 3 on December 30, 2026; and Installment 4 on December 30, 2027. · As of yesteryear: 5.97 · Nature of transaction: Creditors from investment in subsidiaries · Audit committee opinion: The 1st audit committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, it was considered and concluded that the transaction was appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 5.97 · 0.0 · Necessity: It was part of the group's restructuring efforts to eliminate potential conflicts of interest that might arise in the future regarding the waste management business. The sale price of the shares was deemed reasonable and close to the book value per share of CEC. This transaction is expected to generate additional returns from the investment, stemming from the net profit generated from the various ongoing projects of CEC that the company has already undertaken. · Description: Mr. Thirapat Chirapipat sold 3,015 common shares of CEC to CRD at a price of 3,300 Baht per share, totaling 9.95 million Baht. CRD made a payment of 3.98 million Baht for the purchase of the investment in the subsidiary to the seller on February 18, 2021, leaving a balance of 5.97 million Baht, which was due for payment on December 30, 2021, December 30, 2022, and December 30, 2023, with equal installments. Subsequently, the company issued a letter on November 15, 2021, requesting an extension for the payment of the shares for installments 2-4. On December 1, 2022, the company requested to further extend the payment term for installments 2-4, along with a late payment penalty at an interest rate of 5% per annum, starting from January 30, 2022, except for the installment that has not yet reached its due date, until the full payment for each installment of the share purchase is made. The new payment schedule was adjusted as follows: Installment 2 to be paid on December 30, 2025; Installment 3 on December 30, 2026; and Installment 4 on December 30, 2027. · As of yesteryear: 0.49 · Nature of transaction: Interest Payable · Audit committee opinion: The 1st audit committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, it was considered and concluded that the transaction was appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.29 · 0.37 · Necessity: It was part of the group's restructuring efforts to eliminate potential conflicts of interest that might arise in the future regarding the waste management business. The sale price of the shares was deemed reasonable and close to the book value per share of CEC. This transaction is expected to generate additional returns from the investment, stemming from the net profit generated from the various ongoing projects of CEC that the company has already undertaken. · Description: Mr. Thirapat Chirapipat sold 3,015 common shares of CEC to CRD at a price of 3,300 Baht per share, totaling 9.95 million Baht. CRD made a payment of 3.98 million Baht for the purchase of the investment in the subsidiary to the seller on February 18, 2021, leaving a balance of 5.97 million Baht, which was due for payment on December 30, 2021, December 30, 2022, and December 30, 2023, with equal installments. Subsequently, the company issued a letter on November 15, 2021, requesting an extension for the payment of the shares for installments 2-4. On December 1, 2022, the company requested to further extend the payment term for installments 2-4, along with a late payment penalty at an interest rate of 5% per annum, starting from January 30, 2022, except for the installment that has not yet reached its due date, until the full payment for each installment of the share purchase is made. The new payment schedule was adjusted as follows: Installment 2 to be paid on December 30, 2025; Installment 3 on December 30, 2026; and Installment 4 on December 30, 2027. · As of yesteryear: 0.2 · Nature of transaction: Interest Expense · Audit committee opinion: The 1st audit committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, it was considered and concluded that the transaction was appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.2 |
| 0.0 · Necessity: It was part of the group's restructuring efforts to eliminate potential conflicts of interest that might arise in the future regarding the waste management business. The sale price of the shares was deemed reasonable and close to the book value per share of CEC. This transaction is expected to generate additional returns from the investment, stemming from the net profit generated from the various ongoing projects of CEC that the company has already undertaken. · Description: Mr. Chalermsak Nimapan sold 1,050 common shares of CEC to CRD at a price of 3,300 Baht per share, totaling 3.47 million Baht. CRD made a payment of 1.39 million Baht for the purchase of the investment in the subsidiary to the seller on February 18, 2021, leaving a balance of 2.08 million Baht, which was due for payment on December 30, 2021, December 30, 2022, and December 30, 2023, with equal installments. Subsequently, the company issued a letter on November 15, 2021, requesting an extension for the payment of the shares for installments 2-4. On December 1, 2022, the company requested to further extend the payment term for installments 2-4, along with a late payment penalty at an interest rate of 5% per annum, starting from January 30, 2022, except for the installment that has not yet reached its due date, until the full payment for each installment of the share purchase is made. The new payment schedule was adjusted as follows: Installment 2 to be paid on December 30, 2025; Installment 3 on December 30, 2026; and Installment 4 on December 30, 2027. · As of yesteryear: 2.08 · Nature of transaction: Creditors from investment in subsidiaries · Audit committee opinion: The 1st audit committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, it was considered and concluded that the transaction was appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 2.08 · 0.0 · Necessity: It was part of the group's restructuring efforts to eliminate potential conflicts of interest that might arise in the future regarding the waste management business. The sale price of the shares was deemed reasonable and close to the book value per share of CEC. This transaction is expected to generate additional returns from the investment, stemming from the net profit generated from the various ongoing projects of CEC that the company has already undertaken. · Description: Mr. Chalermsak Nimapan sold 1,050 common shares of CEC to CRD at a price of 3,300 Baht per share, totaling 3.47 million Baht. CRD made a payment of 1.39 million Baht for the purchase of the investment in the subsidiary to the seller on February 18, 2021, leaving a balance of 2.08 million Baht, which was due for payment on December 30, 2021, December 30, 2022, and December 30, 2023, with equal installments. Subsequently, the company issued a letter on November 15, 2021, requesting an extension for the payment of the shares for installments 2-4. On December 1, 2022, the company requested to further extend the payment term for installments 2-4, along with a late payment penalty at an interest rate of 5% per annum, starting from January 30, 2022, except for the installment that has not yet reached its due date, until the full payment for each installment of the share purchase is made. The new payment schedule was adjusted as follows: Installment 2 to be paid on December 30, 2025; Installment 3 on December 30, 2026; and Installment 4 on December 30, 2027. · As of yesteryear: 0.17 · Nature of transaction: Interest Payable · Audit committee opinion: The 1st audit committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, it was considered and concluded that the transaction was appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.1 · 0.13 · Necessity: It was part of the group's restructuring efforts to eliminate potential conflicts of interest that might arise in the future regarding the waste management business. The sale price of the shares was deemed reasonable and close to the book value per share of CEC. This transaction is expected to generate additional returns from the investment, stemming from the net profit generated from the various ongoing projects of CEC that the company has already undertaken. · Description: Mr. Chalermsak Nimapan sold 1,050 common shares of CEC to CRD at a price of 3,300 Baht per share, totaling 3.47 million Baht. CRD made a payment of 1.39 million Baht for the purchase of the investment in the subsidiary to the seller on February 18, 2021, leaving a balance of 2.08 million Baht, which was due for payment on December 30, 2021, December 30, 2022, and December 30, 2023, with equal installments. Subsequently, the company issued a letter on November 15, 2021, requesting an extension for the payment of the shares for installments 2-4. On December 1, 2022, the company requested to further extend the payment term for installments 2-4, along with a late payment penalty at an interest rate of 5% per annum, starting from January 30, 2022, except for the installment that has not yet reached its due date, until the full payment for each installment of the share purchase is made. The new payment schedule was adjusted as follows: Installment 2 to be paid on December 30, 2025; Installment 3 on December 30, 2026; and Installment 4 on December 30, 2027. · As of yesteryear: 0.07 · Nature of transaction: Interest Expense · Audit committee opinion: The 1st audit committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, it was considered and concluded that the transaction was appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.07 |
| 0.0 · Necessity: It was part of the group's restructuring efforts to eliminate potential conflicts of interest that might arise in the future regarding the waste management business. The sale price of the shares was deemed reasonable and close to the book value per share of CEC. This transaction is expected to generate additional returns from the investment, stemming from the net profit generated from the various ongoing projects of CEC that the company has already undertaken. · Description: Mrs.Savitre Chirapipat sold 750 common shares of CEC to CRD at a price of 3,300 Baht per share, totaling 2.47 million Baht. CRD made a payment of 0.98 million Baht for the purchase of the investment in the subsidiary to the seller on February 18, 2021, leaving a balance of 1.49 million Baht, which was due for payment on December 30, 2021, December 30, 2022, and December 30, 2023, with equal installments. Subsequently, the company issued a letter on November 15, 2021, requesting an extension for the payment of the shares for installments 2-4. On December 1, 2022, the company requested to further extend the payment term for installments 2-4, along with a late payment penalty at an interest rate of 5% per annum, starting from January 30, 2022, except for the installment that has not yet reached its due date, until the full payment for each installment of the share purchase is made. The new payment schedule was adjusted as follows: Installment 2 to be paid on December 30, 2025; Installment 3 on December 30, 2026; and Installment 4 on December 30, 2027. · As of yesteryear: 1.49 · Nature of transaction: Creditors from investment in subsidiaries · Audit committee opinion: The 1st audit committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, it was considered and concluded that the transaction was appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.49 · 0.0 · Necessity: It was part of the group's restructuring efforts to eliminate potential conflicts of interest that might arise in the future regarding the waste management business. The sale price of the shares was deemed reasonable and close to the book value per share of CEC. This transaction is expected to generate additional returns from the investment, stemming from the net profit generated from the various ongoing projects of CEC that the company has already undertaken. · Description: Mrs.Savitre Chirapipat sold 750 common shares of CEC to CRD at a price of 3,300 Baht per share, totaling 2.47 million Baht. CRD made a payment of 0.98 million Baht for the purchase of the investment in the subsidiary to the seller on February 18, 2021, leaving a balance of 1.49 million Baht, which was due for payment on December 30, 2021, December 30, 2022, and December 30, 2023, with equal installments. Subsequently, the company issued a letter on November 15, 2021, requesting an extension for the payment of the shares for installments 2-4. On December 1, 2022, the company requested to further extend the payment term for installments 2-4, along with a late payment penalty at an interest rate of 5% per annum, starting from January 30, 2022, except for the installment that has not yet reached its due date, until the full payment for each installment of the share purchase is made. The new payment schedule was adjusted as follows: Installment 2 to be paid on December 30, 2025; Installment 3 on December 30, 2026; and Installment 4 on December 30, 2027. · As of yesteryear: 0.12 · Nature of transaction: Interest Payable · Audit committee opinion: The 1st audit committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, it was considered and concluded that the transaction was appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.07 · 0.09 · Necessity: It was part of the group's restructuring efforts to eliminate potential conflicts of interest that might arise in the future regarding the waste management business. The sale price of the shares was deemed reasonable and close to the book value per share of CEC. This transaction is expected to generate additional returns from the investment, stemming from the net profit generated from the various ongoing projects of CEC that the company has already undertaken. · Description: Mrs.Savitre Chirapipat sold 750 common shares of CEC to CRD at a price of 3,300 Baht per share, totaling 2.47 million Baht. CRD made a payment of 0.98 million Baht for the purchase of the investment in the subsidiary to the seller on February 18, 2021, leaving a balance of 1.49 million Baht, which was due for payment on December 30, 2021, December 30, 2022, and December 30, 2023, with equal installments. Subsequently, the company issued a letter on November 15, 2021, requesting an extension for the payment of the shares for installments 2-4. On December 1, 2022, the company requested to further extend the payment term for installments 2-4, along with a late payment penalty at an interest rate of 5% per annum, starting from January 30, 2022, except for the installment that has not yet reached its due date, until the full payment for each installment of the share purchase is made. The new payment schedule was adjusted as follows: Installment 2 to be paid on December 30, 2025; Installment 3 on December 30, 2026; and Installment 4 on December 30, 2027. · As of yesteryear: 0.05 · Nature of transaction: Interest Expense · Audit committee opinion: The 1st audit committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, it was considered and concluded that the transaction was appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.05 |
| 0.0 · Necessity: It was part of the group's restructuring efforts to eliminate potential conflicts of interest that might arise in the future regarding the waste management business. The sale price of the shares was deemed reasonable and close to the book value per share of CEC. This transaction is expected to generate additional returns from the investment, stemming from the net profit generated from the various ongoing projects of CEC that the company has already undertaken. · Description: Mr.Surapol Sriweraskul sold 350 common shares of CEC to CRD at a price of 3,300 Baht per share, totaling 1.15 million Baht. CRD made a payment of 0.46 million Baht for the purchase of the investment in the subsidiary to the seller on February 18, 2021, leaving a balance of 0.69 million Baht, which was due for payment on December 30, 2021, December 30, 2022, and December 30, 2023, with equal installments. Subsequently, the company issued a letter on November 15, 2021, requesting an extension for the payment of the shares for installments 2-4. On December 1, 2022, the company requested to further extend the payment term for installments 2-4, along with a late payment penalty at an interest rate of 5% per annum, starting from January 30, 2022, except for the installment that has not yet reached its due date, until the full payment for each installment of the share purchase is made. The new payment schedule was adjusted as follows: Installment 2 to be paid on December 30, 2025; Installment 3 on December 30, 2026; and Installment 4 on December 30, 2027. · As of yesteryear: 0.69 · Nature of transaction: Creditors from investment in subsidiaries · Audit committee opinion: The 1st audit committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, it was considered and concluded that the transaction was appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.69 · 0.0 · Necessity: It was part of the group's restructuring efforts to eliminate potential conflicts of interest that might arise in the future regarding the waste management business. The sale price of the shares was deemed reasonable and close to the book value per share of CEC. This transaction is expected to generate additional returns from the investment, stemming from the net profit generated from the various ongoing projects of CEC that the company has already undertaken. · Description: Mr.Surapol Sriweraskul sold 350 common shares of CEC to CRD at a price of 3,300 Baht per share, totaling 1.15 million Baht. CRD made a payment of 0.46 million Baht for the purchase of the investment in the subsidiary to the seller on February 18, 2021, leaving a balance of 0.69 million Baht, which was due for payment on December 30, 2021, December 30, 2022, and December 30, 2023, with equal installments. Subsequently, the company issued a letter on November 15, 2021, requesting an extension for the payment of the shares for installments 2-4. On December 1, 2022, the company requested to further extend the payment term for installments 2-4, along with a late payment penalty at an interest rate of 5% per annum, starting from January 30, 2022, except for the installment that has not yet reached its due date, until the full payment for each installment of the share purchase is made. The new payment schedule was adjusted as follows: Installment 2 to be paid on December 30, 2025; Installment 3 on December 30, 2026; and Installment 4 on December 30, 2027. · As of yesteryear: 0.06 · Nature of transaction: Interest Payable · Audit committee opinion: The 1st audit committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, it was considered and concluded that the transaction was appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.04 · 0.04 · Necessity: It was part of the group's restructuring efforts to eliminate potential conflicts of interest that might arise in the future regarding the waste management business. The sale price of the shares was deemed reasonable and close to the book value per share of CEC. This transaction is expected to generate additional returns from the investment, stemming from the net profit generated from the various ongoing projects of CEC that the company has already undertaken. · Description: Mr.Surapol Sriweraskul sold 350 common shares of CEC to CRD at a price of 3,300 Baht per share, totaling 1.15 million Baht. CRD made a payment of 0.46 million Baht for the purchase of the investment in the subsidiary to the seller on February 18, 2021, leaving a balance of 0.69 million Baht, which was due for payment on December 30, 2021, December 30, 2022, and December 30, 2023, with equal installments. Subsequently, the company issued a letter on November 15, 2021, requesting an extension for the payment of the shares for installments 2-4. On December 1, 2022, the company requested to further extend the payment term for installments 2-4, along with a late payment penalty at an interest rate of 5% per annum, starting from January 30, 2022, except for the installment that has not yet reached its due date, until the full payment for each installment of the share purchase is made. The new payment schedule was adjusted as follows: Installment 2 to be paid on December 30, 2025; Installment 3 on December 30, 2026; and Installment 4 on December 30, 2027. · As of yesteryear: 0.02 · Nature of transaction: Interest Expense · Audit committee opinion: The 1st audit committee meeting of 2026, held on February 21, 2026, it was considered and concluded that the transaction was appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.02 |
Policy & Future Trends
Policy, Measures & Approval Process
Measures and Procedures for Approving Related Party Transactions
In the case of related party transactions with individuals who may have potential conflicts of interest or stakeholders, or may have conflicts of interest in the future, the agreements will be in line with standard commercial practices, similar to agreements that a prudent person would make with a counterpart in a similar situation. This will be based on normal market conditions, free from influence, and without the involvement of any directors, executives, or related individuals. The conditions will be reasonable, verifiable, and will not lead to any transfer of benefits. The management of the company can proceed under the principles approved by the board of directors and must prepare a summary report to be presented to the Audit Committee every quarter.
For non-standard transactions, the company will seek the opinion of the Audit Committee regarding the necessity and appropriateness of the transaction. If the Audit Committee lacks expertise in evaluating related party transactions, an independent appraiser, specialist, or auditor will be appointed to provide an opinion to the Audit Committee, which will use this information to make a decision and provide their opinion to the board of directors or shareholders, as applicable, before the transaction takes place.
Future Trends in Related Party Transactions
Policy or Future Trends for Related Party Transactions
In the future, if the company needs to engage in related party transactions, it will establish terms in accordance with normal business practices and market prices that can be compared to terms or prices of similar businesses conducted with third parties. The Audit Committee will provide an opinion on the pricing, compensation rates, and the necessity and appropriateness of the related party transactions. If the Audit Committee lacks the expertise to evaluate the potential related party transaction, the company will appoint an independent appraiser, specialist, or the company’s auditor to provide an opinion on the transaction, which will then be used by the Audit Committee to make a decision and give their opinion to the board of directors or shareholders, as necessary. The company will disclose related party transactions in the notes to the financial statements audited by the company’s auditor. If the company’s common shares are listed on the Market for Alternative Investment (MAI), it will disclose the related party transactions in the 56-1 One Report according to the Securities and Exchange Act and the regulations, announcements, orders, or requirements of the Stock Exchange of Thailand.
Future Related Party Transactions In the future, the company’s directors must comply with the established regulations and will not participate in any transactions where they or any individuals may have a conflict of interest with the company. Such transactions must be disclosed to the board of directors for consideration. The company must ensure compliance with the Securities and Exchange Act, regulations, announcements, orders, or requirements of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including the disclosure of related party transactions and in accordance with accounting standards set by the Accounting Profession Council. Additionally, the company will not engage in related party transactions that are outside the company’s normal business operations.
